Size shouldn’t matter!

In a second article where Read But Never Red goes slightly ‘off piste’ from writing exclusively about Manchester City, we once again delve into the thoughts of a football manager and head of youth development, this time on the topic of aspiring goalkeepers.

The often ‘colourful’ and controversial manager is concerned that many professional clubs in England are inadvertently blighting the potential of youngsters, by imposing strict height requirements before even considering them for admission to football academies up and down the country.

He has asked to remain anonymous and RBNR is happy to respect those wishes.

When it comes to goalkeepers Manchester City are blessed with having one of the finest in the world in the shape of Joe Hart.

Save of the Season - Joe Hart produced a number of breathtaking stops en-route to his Golden Glove award. Courtesy@MCFC

Save of the Season – Joe Hart produced a number of breathtaking stops en-route to his Golden Glove award. Courtesy@MCFC

With a nice round 300 City first team appearances under his belt, more than 50 England caps and four of the last five Golden Glove Awards for keeping clean sheets in the Premier League, Joe stands proud and tall in his profession.

At 6ft 5” (that’s 1.96m in ‘new money’) and 28-years of age, Joe’s best playing years are more than likely still ahead of him – and that’s taking into account two PL title wins and FA & League Cup winning medals already in his collection.

Jumping Joe - Hart frustrated Lionel Messi in City 's Champions League encounters with Barcelona - saving a penalty at the Etihad before putting on a world class show at the Nou Camp. Courtesy@MCFC

Jumping Joe – Hart frustrated Lionel Messi in City ‘s Champions League encounters with Barcelona – saving a penalty at the Etihad before putting on a world class show at the Nou Camp. Courtesy@MCFC

Hart follows in a long line of City goalkeeping giants, legends such as Frank Swift, Bert Trautmann and Joe Corrigan, men big in both stature and achievement.

The quartet of City keepers were fortunate that Mother Nature gave them the natural height to go with their athletic ability.

But what happens if an aspiring youngster doesn’t measure up to the rigid, and many would say, short-sighted criteria of ‘if you’re not 6ft or more by the age of 16, you can forget about being a goalkeeper’?

Our mystery football manager and youth development expert shared his experiences, tales which should encourage a far more flexible and enlightened approach, when looking to identify young goalkeeping talent.

Legend - Bert Trautmann then man who helped City win the FA Cup in 1956 with a broken neck - just incredible. Courtesy@MCFC

Legend – Bert Trautmann then man who helped City win the FA Cup in 1956 with a broken neck – just incredible. Courtesy@MCFC

30 years ago a teenager was making a name for himself in his local league as a brilliant goalkeeper. His dream was to be a professional footballer, but how many of us achieve our dreams in life?

So often the dreams remains just that…people fall short of their aspirations and dreams go unfulfilled.

In this instance the lad in question faced the prospect of coming up short – two inches to be precise. He was 5ft 10” tall in a world full of 6ft+ strikers.

How many times did the boy hear the feedback “Great keeper, but nowhere near tall enough…” it was discouraging and frustrating to say the least.

Desperate to prove people wrong the boy took action to prevent his career ending before it had even begun.

He joined a gymnastics club to enhance his agility, took up athletics to speed up his sprinting, he even indulged in ‘Billy Elliot-style’ dance classes to improve his overall footwork.

If his lack of height was deemed an impediment he was determined to overcome it by excelling in other areas of his game.

It paid off. His quality and consistency of performance caught the eye of more and more scouts. Eventually, to his surprise, he was offered a trial at a major club in the First Division – today’s Premier League.

Big Joe - Corrigan never had any difficulties meeting the height criteria for a goalkeeper.

Big Joe – Corrigan never had any difficulties meeting the height criteria for a goalkeeper.

Thrilled at the prospect of finally getting a shot at the big time, the boy was nonetheless, still carrying the mental burden of constantly worrying about his perceived lack of height.

As he walked from the changing room to the pitch for his trial match, a familiar figure approached the nervous teenager – the manager of the club’s first team.

“Hello son, you’re not very tall for a keeper are you?”

His heart sank. His worst fears were being realised before he’d even stepped onto the pitch. What came next from the famous manager was totally unexpected.

“Well you listen to me, those strikers may be taller than you but they can’t use their f**kin hands can they, so with your arms in the air I reckon that makes you about 7ft f**kin tall – so nothing to worry about!”

As pep talks go, it was about as good as it gets. The trial went like a dream, the young lad was signed as a professional and prospered in a career spanning 700 first team appearances.

City Great - Frank Swift was one of the wonderful goalkeepers scattered through the history of Manchester City. Courtesy@MCFC

City Great – Frank Swift was one of the wonderful goalkeepers scattered through the history of Manchester City. Courtesy@MCFC

The question posed by our unidentified contributor, our football youth development expert, is could such a positive scenario happen today, in the land of ritzy academies?

He fears it highly unlikely.

“Clubs nowadays are far too prescriptive and conditioned to putting ticks in boxes – irrespective of natural ability. The notion of a young keeper, who doesn’t hit the 6ft mark, progressing at a professional English club is highly fanciful.”

He tells the story of a young keeper who found himself discarded by one leading club in the North West of England, because his parents were comparatively short and it was assumed the lad would inherit their genes.

The keeper in question was an adopted child, but the club couldn’t see beyond their stereotypical prejudice, didn’t bother to do their homework and cast him aside.

Their loss was a bitter local rival’s gain, and the player went on to an illustrious career.

Giant character - John 'Budgie' Burridge was 'short' by goalkeeping standards, but he was the oldest player to grace the Premier League when he played for City in 1995.

Giant character – John ‘Budgie’ Burridge was ‘short’ by goalkeeping standards, but he was the oldest player to grace the Premier League when he played for City in 1995.

Two goalkeepers – one being the oldest to ever play in the Premier League, the other being just about the most successful keeper of all time – fell short of the 6ft mark.

One of the domestic game’s most colourful of characters, John ‘Budgie’ Burridge, came on as a half time substitute to play for Manchester City against Newcastle United on April 29th, 1995. He was 43yrs 4 months and 26-days young, he kept a clean sheet that day…and he was just 5ft 11” tall.

Burridge made four appearances for City after being signed by manager, Brian Horton, as cover for first choice Tony Coton. In total he played 771 times for 29 different teams in a career spanning nearly 30 years – a remarkable achievement.

Iker Casillas is one of the most successful keepers ever in the history of football, but at less than 6ft tall probably wouldn't have been given a trial by many clubs in England.

Iker Casillas is one of the most successful keepers ever in the history of football, but at less than 6ft tall probably wouldn’t have been given a trial by many clubs in England.

But when it comes to footballing glory there’s not many who can top 5ft 11½” Iker Casillas of Real Madrid and Spain – the winner of a World Cup and 2 European Championships at international level, the Spanish skipper has amassed 3 Champions League medals, 2 UEFA Super Cups, a FIFA Club World Cup, an Intercontinental Cup, 5 La Liga titles, 2 Copa del Rey victories and 4 Supercopa de Espana wins – not too shabby for a man who wouldn’t meet the basic admission requirements for clubs in the lower reaches of the professional game in this country.

England's undisputed Number One - Joe Hart.

England’s undisputed Number One – Joe Hart.

And, despite the obvious idiocy of the stipulations that govern whether a less than 6ft keeper gets the chance of a professional contract in England, our guest contributor is in no doubt:

“The answer is an emphatic NO!”

 

By David Walker

 

Special Offer…MCFC T-SHIRT & ARTWORK for FATHER’S DAY – June 21st

In collaboration with our friends at Art of Football http://art-of-football.com/collections/all/man-city all Read But Never Red readers can benefit from a 10% discount on MCFC t-shirts and prints.

City win the title - Sergio is mobbed by his team mates on May 13th, 2012.

City win the title – Aguerooooo 93:20 on May 13th, 2012.

City win the title - Sergio is mobbed by his team mates on May 13th, 2012.

Shirt off – Sergio is mobbed by his team mates on May 13th, 2012.

The City collection includes the ‘Agueroooooo, the ‘Last Minute’ that followed the 93:20 goal and the always memorable ‘Why Always Me’ Mario Balotelli moment, as City set about stuffing United 6-1 – ALL ICONIC IMAGES in City’s glorious recent past.

Why Always Me? - Mad Mario's famous 6-1 celebration.

Why Always Me? – Mad Mario’s famous 6-1 celebration.

Just quote code RBNR to save 10% on all orders – what a great gift for any MCFC supporting Father…Who’s the Daddy?

Follow on Twitter @Art_of_Football

 

www.readbutneverred.com @ReadButNeverRed @djwskyblu

 

12 Comments

  1. June 15, 2015  7:39 pm by Doug Henshaw Reply

    Such a shame just because your not 6ft doesn't mean you won't make a good keeper. Les Green of Derby County springs to mind.

    • June 15, 2015  8:28 pm by David Walker Reply

      It looks to be that way nowadays Doug. Certainly the guy we're talking to has documentation that proves his point.

  2. June 15, 2015  8:12 pm by GeorgeInIsrael Reply

    If I remember correctly, Harry Dowd was also under 6'

    • June 15, 2015  8:26 pm by David Walker Reply

      He was indeed George - nice observation. RIP Harry.

  3. June 15, 2015  9:56 pm by Ian Barton Reply

    I still have the programme from my first ever game City v Fulham 4th September 1959. They had a list of the player with height etc. Bert was the tallest in the squad at 6' 0".

    • June 15, 2015  10:59 pm by David Walker Reply

      I'm so glad your comment wasn't to say Bert was 5ft 11-and-three-quarter inches tall - that would've made me feel stupid...more than I actually am ;-) Thanks fella.

  4. June 15, 2015  10:31 pm by paul jackson Reply

    If my memory serves me right Paul cooper was not massive by keepers standards and if I not wrong he held a record for saving pens!!

    • June 15, 2015  10:57 pm by David Walker Reply

      I reckon you're right Paul - Cooper was a prodigious penalty stopper.

  5. June 25, 2015  12:46 am by goonermichael Reply

    Interesting article. My friend;s son was told he would be released by a premier league club if he didn't grow 2 inches. He didn't so they released him

    • June 27, 2015  12:48 am by David Walker Reply

      Thanks Gooner. One can only hope the lad confounded the doubters and went on to carve out a decent career as a professional keeper. Surely if you're good enough then you're good enough - end of argument.

  6. June 29, 2015  7:31 am by Stephen Reply

    Interesting piece. Think we are all difficult of either assumptions or snap judgements. Problem is 'smaller' keepers will likely have to work twice as hard. However, agility and hands are paramount -love the f**king 7ft tall comparison. Did not realise you had articles over the summer so thought I would come on to say thanks

    • June 29, 2015  2:02 pm by David Walker Reply

      Cheers Stephen. The blogs are a little more sporadic in the off season but there's a coontroversial one on the way in conjunction with the football manager who has asked to remain anonynmous. In addition there's the possibility of a 'mini-series' based on the exploits and views of a Man City Superfan who goes everywhere to watch his beloved Blues. Of course, there is also the small matter of who will City spend £150m-£200m on this summer, and who departs the Etihad. At least I won't have to write about a new City manager before August 8th.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.